Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Practice Makes Permanent

Practice doesn't make perfect, practice makes permanent. Just another axiom designed to make moms feel guilty and/or inadequate. According to Dr. Suzuki, not only does your child have to practice "only on the days he eats," but it has to be good quality, too, or you're just developing bad habits. The pressure! My kids definitely aren't the prodigies you see on PBS, but they won't be the ones who later lament the fact that their mom didn't make them practice as kids, I promise you that! On September 15, all of them started a One Hundred Days in a Row challenge. Posting our progress on the blog will motivate me to keep it up, so thanks for being my enforcers! Here are some of my practicing motivators, in hopes that you'll share your ideas with me...



Leaving the instruments out until all the practicing is done. It makes the task seem easier if you can get started on it quickly, and the instrument is a visual reminder. Golda likes to go through one book at a time and set each one aside as she finishes it. Her main motivation for doing well is that she doesn't want to hear my footsteps coming toward her room, which tends to happen when a note or a rhythm is repeatedly wrong.


Extreme measures: (no pun intended) practicing at the same time when we're in a hurry. I call this "turbo speed practicing." If it's a day where we're out the door early, at least I feel like we got something done beforehand. It makes for a chaotic ride, though!
Involving friends, as in, "Hey, kids! It's time for music class! Ari will show you how to hold the bow!" That works better than waiting until all the friends are gone because Ari loves to be a teacher, and Freestone loves to have an audience. A friend favorite is "rhythm class," where Freestone gets his Twinkle variation clapping done and all the kids have fun.
Freestone loves to count things. When it's time to practice, I grab a handful of some random item, like crayons or flash cards and each time he does what I ask, he gets one. Coins are a big favorite. He sits on a circular rug and puts a coin on the edge of the rug until the coins circle all the way around. Today, I let him open the package Tiffany gave me. It was a treasure trove of fun ideas. We put the candy corns in the love box one at a time. Tomorrow, we'll use the sugar babies, and the next day, he'll get to turn a page of the Halloween book each time he plays something. Thanks, Tiffany! Inspiration is more fun when it's colorful!


Ari loves to check things off. If I give her a "100 times chart," she'll practice forever, trying to fill in the chart. Ruby's style is to work by herself for awhile, then go through everything with me to smooth out what she's learned. That way, everything gets done twice as many times, once alone and once with me. She gets frustrated if I help her before she's had a chance to work it out on her own.

My best weapon is the Minnie Mouse Board. All the practicing that doesn't get done before school gets written on a dry-erase board so we can keep track of what still has to be done. It's called Minnie Mouse because it lists what, hopefully, are "mini" assignments, if you've gotten most of your work done before school. Now I write homework assignments, reading and class/lesson times on it, too, so everybody knows what to do, when. It's weird what will work and what won't, but the Minnie Mouse Board seems to do the trick. As of now, Freestone is finished with practicing, Xanthe has 10 more minutes, Golda has 20, Ari 18 more, Ruby has 35 more...I can't remember all this stuff without a cheat sheet!

If you're a parent with practicing (or non-practicing!) kids, give me all your secrets. (I can just picture Golda trying to tell me that she's going to become a "non-practicing flutist.") As you know, our bag of tricks has to be refilled daily. With nine days down and 91 to go, I'm going to need some more ideas!

11 comments:

Sher said...

I like your 100 days idea. I struggle with getting my daugther to practice piano. There is the power struggle if me being her teacher AND trying to sit down to help her practice, too.
I think it's easier, as the teacher, to say, go home and practice, and let them go on their way, and leave it to the parent to see to it.
Much harder being the parent.
I remember my Mom offering rewards ($$, toys, time to play, etc) with my siblings to get them to practice. Of course, she never had to do this with me, because I was always very diligent.
p.s. sorry, I didn't make it over last night. We didn't get home until after 9, and after getting kids to bed I figured it was too late.
I don't have time today, but I'll call you tomorrow and figure it out.
Thanks!

Michelle said...

Okay, so see this is why I am scared of Brittany starting an instrument. she has a clueless mother! I was in choir for years, I can tell what sounds wrong(we hope) but I have no idea how to do any of it right! Gonna have to find a good teacher aren't I?

Maria said...

My mom let me pick out a pair of shoes every 100 days I practiced in a row. It worked from 5th grade until 9th grade!!! I didn't miss a day. On the days I was out of town I had to listen to the CD for twice as long as I was supposed to practice. I love the 100 days in a row!!! Good luck!

Melinda Lomax & Fam said...

Wow! You are an inspiration as always. Thanks for sharing your enthusiam!

SSWS said...

Bribing, torture.....threats, tears, drama..what else? I should try some of your tricks. I don't claim that mine are good, but it's pretty much what we resort too. Actually, I think consistency is the best thing. If you go for a few days without practicing, it's hard to start up again. I can't believe all the minutes you keep track of! Another good post.

Jennifer said...

Now, I must admit that my kids are like the fabled cobbler's barefoot family when it comes to practicing. You've inspired me to be better!

Consistency is key (no pun intended!) Practicing does have to be scheduled. My trumpet-blaring son knows he has different "practice slots" on different days, geared around bedtimes for the younger ones and other lessons.

I know that some of my students merely turn into wistful clockwatchers if they're assigned a set number of minutes. So I instead give them specific instructions on how many times to go through a piece, and what goals to focus on in the repetitions (dynamics, rhythm, etc.) Generally they'll end up practicing the amount of time I want, but in a more guided, efficient way (I hope!)

After warm-ups, start practicing with the hardest piece when the mind is fresh to attack it.

I sometimes encourage the "dartboard approach" to shake things up. Close your eyes, spin your finger and land it on your music. Start playing at that measure, to the end, then from the beginning to where you touched. There's a certain skill involved in being able to start a piece at any point.

I think the best way to motivate instrument practice is to surround children with examples of what they can become. You're doing a great job of that!

Jenny said...

I am not up to this point yet. We are still practicing wiping bums and remembering show and tell. I don't think I want to delve into this kind of challenge. I am glad you are so diligent!

Anonymous said...

I love that you do different things for each child. Also the Minnie Mouse Board sounds like a good idea!

Beeswax said...

I just clicked over from your book club blog. Don't buy Wideacre! Is BAD! My favorite Gregory has been "The Queen's Fool".

My kids are not practicing their piano lessons right now. They are wrestling in front of the piano. All four of them.

Beeswax said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
love.boxes said...

You are so inspiring Circ. I haven't even dared to start this yet. So far c's only musical experience is choir. I really need to get a piano bench and a teacher.